Read Reviews From Your State

Wisconsin Mutual Review

Wisconsin Mutual Company Information

Customer Rating:
Rating: 2.520 Reviews Wisconsin Mutual has received an average of 2.5 stars out of 5 based on 20 user reviews.

Company History:
Wisconsin Tornado Mutual Insurance Company was founded in 1903. The company changed its name to Wisconsin Mutual Insurance in 1946 and moved to its current location in 1990. Currently Wisconsin Mutual only writes business in Wisconsin. It insures over 40,000 properties and 70,000 automobiles. The company ranks in the top 10 companies in Wisconsin in direct written premiums and property coverage in Homeowner premiums and Farmowner premiums. ..Read More

Lines of Insurance:
Auto, Homeowners

States licensed to sell insurance in:
WI

Wisconsin Mutual Satisfaction Survey

Overall, how satisfied are you, with Wisconsin Mutual?


Contact Information for Wisconsin Mutual

Company Contact Info:
President   Daniel A. Keyes
8201 Excelsior Drive
Madison, WI 53717
608-836-4663

Wisconsin Mutual Reviews and Customer Comments

"We had a roof with wind damage and filed a claim. When the adjuster came to see the roof he said "not much going on up there." He wanted to patch it. You cannot patch this roof He sent us a check for a very low amount and sent it out after the fact without giving us any negotiating power. When we received the low amount check we complained. They sent us a letter dropping our policy saying it was because our roof was in very bad shape. Run run as far as you can"
Commented on 2014-09-08 20:22:49 EST
"Please stay away from this company. If you are insured with them know drop them because they will not honor their part of the insurance agreement. They lie and drag out your claim for months. Wisconsin mutual should be shut down. "
Commented on 2014-07-25 09:47:26 EST
"Would not recommend this company to anyone anytime"
Commented on 2014-06-12 22:32:54 EST
"they explained to me what I was entitled to then after making promises as to the claim they reneged on and lied. When I filed a complaint with the state their response was pure lies. The reasons for not paying what they were supposed to are a moving target and change with every time they open their mouths."
Commented on 2014-01-11 17:07:55 EST
"My home burned down. Adjuster never contacted me despite numerous attempts to file the claim. When I finally got a name and phone number I called and it seemed to go smoothly after 3 months she was supposed to call me to discuss expenses for the following next 3 months that were supposed to be covered. Suddenly everything she promised and said was part of the policy gone. She never called me as promised then when I called her she gave me an excuse about where I was currently staying. When I contacted her boss I got a cold nasty email. When I filed a complaint with the state they responded with a letter that was nothing but lies. I never actually got a printed policy only one that was online that didn't actually explain anything. I relied on what the adjuster told me then reneged on. The reasoning they are using is a moving target. It changes with every response.Don't bother with this company. You won't actually get what you pay for."
Commented on 2013-11-25 13:53:19 EST
View All Comments
View All Companies Reviewed
Huge Insurance Savings! Click to Get Free Quotes & Save Up To 60%
Get Auto Insurance Quotes from Top Companies:
Get Life Insurance Quotes from Top Companies:
Get Home Insurance Quotes from Top Companies:
Get Health Insurance Quotes from Top Companies:
Read Reviews From Your State
Hide