FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Call us today for a free consultation (855) 466-5776

Insurance Company Reviews

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Call us today for a free consultation (855) 466-5776

Your Insurance Company Reviewed

Read Reviews From Your State:

Wisconsin Mutual Review

Wisconsin Mutual Company Overview

Customer Rating:
Rating: 2.038 Reviews Wisconsin Mutual has received an average of 2.0 stars out of 5 based on 38 user reviews.

Company History:
Wisconsin Tornado Mutual Insurance Company was founded in 1903. The company changed its name to Wisconsin Mutual Insurance in 1946 and moved to its current location in 1990. Currently Wisconsin Mutual only writes business in Wisconsin. It insures over 40,000 properties and 70,000 automobiles. The company ranks in the top 10 companies in Wisconsin in direct written premiums and property coverage in Homeowner premiums and Farmowner premiums. ..Read More

Lines of Insurance:
Auto, Homeowners

States licensed to sell insurance in:

Wisconsin Mutual Satisfaction Survey

Overall, how satisfied are you, with Wisconsin Mutual?

  1. Please select your insurance company from the following list:

  2. What insurance policy/policies do you have with this company?
    (select all that apply)
    Auto   Home   Health   Life   Other

  3. How long have you had a policy with this company?
    Less Than 1 Month
    1 to 6 Months
    6 Months to 1 Year
    1 to 3 Years
    Over 3 Years

  4. Overall, how satisfied are you, with your insurance company?
    Extremely Satisfied
    Very Satisfied
    Somewhat Satisfied
    Very Unsatisfied

  5. How likely are you to renew your insurance policy/policies with this insurance company?
    Might or Might Not
    Probably Not
    Definitely Not

  6. Would you recommend this insurance company to your friends and family?
    Might or Might Not
    Probably Not
    Definitely Not

  7. Have you ever had occasion to file a claim with your company?
    YES   NO

  8. Please provide any comments about your insurance company that would be useful to other consumers.


Contact Information for Wisconsin Mutual

Company Contact Info:
President   Daniel A. Keyes
8201 Excelsior Drive
Madison, WI 53717

Wisconsin Mutual Reviews and Customer Comments

"This company is the definition of bad faith outlined in INS 6.11 They were absolutely horrible to work with and have denied coverage that was additional coverage that we paid for. Our agent sold this as a great company and it has been one of the worst Save yourself the hassle and find a reputable company that will care for you when you need them most"
Commented on 2019-09-05 13:02:08 EST
"Adjuster was rude, looked down on us, still waiting for money to fix house. Will not cover all damages. One other friend of mine had same adjuster and was very rude to them. Adjuster is a complete *hole. Am dropping all insurance with this worthless back stabbing company"
Commented on 2019-08-25 13:18:21 EST
"We had a claim on a broken window. Out insurance agent told us to get some quotes so we did. Called him back with quotes and couldnt get a hold of him. A few weeks later his wife finally called saying he was injured and that we should call the main office. We did and nobody called us back in a week so I called again and left a message stating how upset I was and someone finally called back. Then I was given to another person who asked for several emails of the quotes which she had a hard time reading then started to give me a runaround. Finally I was told a check would be mailed out on a Tuesday, by Friday I still had not received it. When I emailed asking about it she gave me someone elses email to contact them. So I contacted yet a 4th person and havent gotten an answer yet. Very poor customer service"
Commented on 2019-07-12 15:41:04 EST
"After record breaking snowfalls, our pole barn roof collapsed. Wisconsin Mutual falsely claimed that we did not have 'Snow damage coverage.' DO NOT BUY INSURANCE FROM THESE SCAMMERS."
Commented on 2019-02-26 18:03:24 EST
"Storm damage claim and the adjuster was very rude and made us feel like we did something wrong. Does not care about the customer. Poor customer service."
Commented on 2018-11-19 08:48:35 EST
View All Comments
Read Reviews From Your State: