Insurance Company Reviews

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

Your Insurance Company Reviewed

Read Reviews From Your State:

New York Central Mutual Review

New York Central Mutual Company Overview

Customer Rating:
Rating: 2.088 Reviews New York Central Mutual has received an average of 2.0 stars out of 5 based on 88 user reviews.

Company History:
New York Central Mutual was founded in 1899 by VanNess D. Robinson. In 2001 the company's newest subsidiary, A. Central Insurance Company, was launched. Also in 2001, the Central Services Group was formed in order to act as an umbrella organization for NYCM's growing operations. Currently the company employs over 1000 people and has over 490,000 policies in force. ..Read More

Lines of Insurance:

States licensed to sell insurance in:

New York Central Mutual Satisfaction Survey

Overall, how satisfied are you, with New York Central Mutual?

  1. Please select your insurance company from the following list:

  2. What insurance policy/policies do you have with this company?
    (select all that apply)
    Auto   Home   Health   Life   Other

  3. How long have you had a policy with this company?
    Less Than 1 Month
    1 to 6 Months
    6 Months to 1 Year
    1 to 3 Years
    Over 3 Years

  4. Overall, how satisfied are you, with your insurance company?
    Extremely Satisfied
    Very Satisfied
    Somewhat Satisfied
    Very Unsatisfied

  5. How likely are you to renew your insurance policy/policies with this insurance company?
    Might or Might Not
    Probably Not
    Definitely Not

  6. Would you recommend this insurance company to your friends and family?
    Might or Might Not
    Probably Not
    Definitely Not

  7. Have you ever had occasion to file a claim with your company?
    YES   NO

  8. Please provide any comments about your insurance company that would be useful to other consumers.


Contact Information for New York Central Mutual

Company Contact Info:
President   V. Daniel Robinson II
1899 Central Plaza East
Edmeston, NY 13335

New York Central Mutual Reviews and Customer Comments

"Great company and easy to work with."
Commented on 2019-03-06 19:49:28 EST
"Dont waste your time with NYCM Insurance Company. I just bought my new auto policy with them and they are already cancelling me. I called to find out why and its due to a previous violation 2 years ago...cancelling me over a ZERO POINT VIOLATION Why underwrite the policy to begin with They also refuse to insure my new house due to a flat roof, even though they insured my last house in NY with a flat roof for over 10 years. So now Im already looking for a new insurance company. Dont waste your time with NYCM. They apparently just look for any and every reason not to insure you, even if it doesnt make sense. Not to mention extremely rude customer service reps. Save yourself the hassle and go elsewhere"
Commented on 2019-02-20 20:17:35 EST
"Started homeowner claim 35 - it's now 320 and I'm being told I need to wait UNTIL WED. to see if my faxemail has been received sent Monday. My rep won't speak to me, I've been passed to 3 other reps, and I'm very frustrated. With the amount of work I'VE HAD TO DO, this should be resolved by now."
Commented on 2018-03-20 09:34:08 EST
"Very poor company. I am going to sue they to receive what is rightly mine. Very bogus in its approach."
Commented on 2017-10-17 18:56:03 EST
"Company is very eager to cancel your policy. Cost me 240 with NYS due to policy being canceled. Never will do business with this company again"
Commented on 2017-09-22 11:47:30 EST
View All Comments
Read Reviews From Your State:

FREE Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!